Carney & Wehofer Family
 Genealogy Pages

John CASE, Sr.

John CASE, Sr.[1, 2, 3, 4, 5]

Male 1616 - 1704  (88 years)

Personal Information    |    Notes    |    Sources    |    All    |    PDF

  • Name John CASE 
    Suffix Sr. 
    Born 1615-1616  Gravesend, Kent, Middlesex, England Find all individuals with events at this location  [6
    • Birth Surety: 2
    Gender Male 
    AFN 31MD-M2 
    FamilySearch ID LB8D-PFQ 
    Sold 6 pieces of Land in Hartford 1 Feb 1640  [7
    Sold all his land in Hartford to William Gibbines 
    Occupation   [7
    Assemblyman: representative 
    Occupation 14 Oct 1669  Simsbury, Hartford, Connecticut, British Colonial America Find all individuals with events at this location  [7
    Constable: preserved the peace, executed orders of courts and conducted meetings of the inhabitants 
    _UID 0AF5BC7725E740BE8D09F99FE5627EEB1A5E 
    Died 21 Feb 1704  Simsbury, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location 
    • Death Surety: 3
    Buried Simsbury, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location 
    Person ID I17036  Carney Wehofer 2024 Genealogy
    Last Modified 12 Dec 2022 

    Father John CASE,   b. Abt 1586, France Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. Yes, date unknown 
    Mother Elizabeth PURCHASE,   b. Abt 1595, Gravesend, Kent, Middlesex, England Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. Yes, date unknown 
    Family ID F8618  Group Sheet  |  Family Chart

    Family 1 Sarah SPENCER,   b. 7 Mar 1636, Boston, Suffolk County, Massachusetts Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 3 Nov 1691, Windsor, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 55 years) 
    Married Bef 17 Aug 1656  Hartford, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location  [8
    • Surety:0
    Children 
     1. Elizabeth CASE,   b. Sep 1658, Windsor, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 9 Oct 1718, Windsor, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age ~ 60 years)
     2. Mary CASE,   b. 22 Jun 1660, Windsor, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 22 Aug 1725, Farmington, New Haven, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 65 years)
     3. John CASE, Jr.,   b. 5 Nov 1662, Windsor, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 22 May 1733, Simsbury, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 70 years)
     4. William James CASE,   b. 5 Jun 1665, Windsor, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 31 Mar 1700, Simsbury, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 34 years)
     5. Samuel CASE,   b. 1 Jun 1667, Windsor, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 30 Jul 1725, Simsbury, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 58 years)
     6. Richard CASE,   b. 27 Aug 1669, Simsbury, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 27 Apr 1746, Bloomfield, Hartford, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 76 years)
     7. Bartholomew CASE,   b. 1 Oct 1670, Simsbury, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 25 Oct 1725, Simsbury, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 55 years)
     8. Joseph CASE,   b. 6 Apr 1674, Simsbury, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 11 Aug 1748, Simsbury, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 74 years)
     9. Sarah CASE,   b. 14 Aug 1676, Simsbury, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 2 May 1704, Simsbury, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 27 years)
     10. Abigail CASE,   b. 4 May 1682, Simsbury, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 30 May 1714  (Age 32 years)
    Last Modified 29 Aug 2016 
    Family ID F8041  Group Sheet  |  Family Chart

    Family 2 Elizabeth MOORE,   b. 1638, Windsor, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 23 Jul 1728, Windsor, Hartford County, Connecticut Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 90 years) 
    Married Aft Dec 1682 
    • Surety:2
    Last Modified 29 Aug 2016 
    Family ID F8446  Group Sheet  |  Family Chart

  • Notes 
    • BIOGRAPHY: Reference: 974.6 Cutter, C991, V.2 pp 795-796, V.3 pp 1674-1682 "Commemorative Biographical record of Hartford Co. Connecticut" p 524 John Case, the founder of the Case family in america was born in Aylesham, England in 1616, the year that William Shakespeare died. He sailed from Gravesend, England, sep 2 1635 on the ship Dorset and landed at Newport, R.I., but settled in Windsor, CT. He spent some years in Newton on Long Island, but in 1656 he returned to CT and in 1667 settled in Simsbury, formerly know as Massaco. In 1657 he married Sarah. John Case was recoginzed for his moral influence as well as his business integrity.
      BIOGRAPHY: John was a farmer and a landowner, came to America in 1635, settling at Hartford, CT. He moved to Newtown, Long Island, but returned to CT and settled in the town of Windsor in 1656. He was one of the founders of Simsbury, in 1669. John had a brother Richard at Hartford, residing there in 1660. The family of John joined the church at Farmington 4 Jul 1693 (Church Records at Farmington), and was made Constable of "Massacco' in 1669, the first in the town. In 1670 he was appointed to the general court of Simsbury.

      The First Settlers of Simsbury-Taken from the Simsbury Historical Society IN MEMORIES SECTION [this is where the 1616 birth date for John was located] but cannot find any other
      credible sources for his birth. The Birth location given in the "First Settlers of Simsbury" was Aylesham. There is no evidence of John's parentage out there. If you want to add parents, please provide a credible source.
      ***********************
      There does not appear to be any documentary evidence that John Case's middle name was Thurston. If someone has something, please post it. Also, the Aylesham parish register does not begin as early as 1616. When ADDING PARENTS, Please indicate sources.

      John Case came to America at age 19 years. He supposedly came on the ship "Dorset". The 'Dorset' sailed from Gravesend, Kent September 30, 1635, bound for Bermuda. There was a Wm. Casse aboard, age 19.

      He married first to Sarah Spencer, she was the mother of ALL of his children. He married second to Elizabeth (Moore) Loomis and had NO children with her!!

      In February 1640 John Case conveyed 6 parcels of land to Wm. Gibbons.
      This land was in the vicinity of Hartford, Connecticut, which shows him to be a resident there and of an age to convey land.
      He lived in New Nederlands near Brooklyn 13 August 1666 with his wife Sarah who was born in 1636. He was in New London in 1656 and next year moved to Windsor. He was constable of Simsbury 1669, Deputy 1670-1691.
      His wife Sarah died 3 November 1691 aged 55 years.
      John Case married as his second wife Elizabeth, born in 1638, widow of Nathaniel Loomis and daughter of John Moore.
      Elizabeth died July 1728 aged 90 years. John Case died 21 February 1704.

      Most of the information on John Case b. 1616 came from the book written by Ruth Cost Duncan. A copy is located in the Church of Jesus Christ's Genealogy Library located in Salt Lake City, Utah.
      John resided in Windsor until 1669 when he removed to Simsbury and settled in the area known as "Weatogue". He was appointed constable for Massaco by the General Court 14 Oct 1669. He represented his town at the General Court in 1670 and several times afterwards.
      Johns will dated 21 Nov 1700 named his wife, Elizabeth, six sons and four daughters. Samuel Spencer of Hartford and John Case, his son, were executors.
      ----------------------------
      Excerpt From [John Case Pages 66-69] - The Case Family of Connecticut and Long Island TAG 34:65-78 IN Memories Section.

      "Matthew Grant's ''Old Church Record" of Windsor, so-called,
      notes on 17 Aug. 1611 that John case had by
      then had six children born at Windsor; the ones whose
      births he entered on another page were ii to vi inclusive
      and ix, though 5arah (ixJ with a slightly different
      date was also entered in Simsbury recorded where
      children vii to x were recorded."

      Children of John Case and Sarah Spencer:

      i. Elizabeth, b. ca. 1658, probably at Maspeth Kills; d. at Simsbury, 9 Oct. 1718 ("was well & dyed in about 6 ours time");
      m. (1) at Windsor, 30 Apr. 1674, Joseph Lewis, who d. at Simsbury in 168o (four children);
      m. (2 ) ca. 16841 John Tuller, who d. at Simsbury slightly before 28 Jan. 1741/2 (six children).

      ii. Mary, b. Windsor 22 June 1660; d. Simsbury, 22 Aug. 1725;
      m. (1) in 1675, William Alderman, who d. at Farmington in the summer of 1697 (six children);
      m. (2) at Simsbury, 30 Mar. 1698/9, Sergt. James Hillyer, who d. at Simsbury 28 July 1720 (one child) .

      iii. John, b. Windsor S Nov. 1662; d. at Simsbury 1 22 May 1733;
      m. (1) at Simsbury, 12 Sept. 1684, Mary3 Olcott, dau. of Thomas2 Olcott (Thomas1) by Mary Cullick, and she d. in 1685, perhaps in childbirth;
      m. ( 2) in 1687, Sarah3 Holcombe, b. at Windsor 2 3 June 1668, dau. of Joshua2 Holcombe (Thomas1) by Ruth Sherwood (one child by Mary, six by Sarah).

      iv. William, b. Windsor 5 June 1665, but the birth entry in the Colony record erroneously calls him James; d. at Simsbury 31 Mar. 1700; m. Elizabeth3 Holcombe, b. 4 Apr. 1670, d . 26 Feb. 1762, dau. of Joshua2 Holcombe (Thomas1 ) by Ruth Sherwood, and therefore sister of the second wife of John2 Case . She m. (2 ) at Simsbury, 10 Mar. 1703/4, Deacon John Slater, Jr., b. at Simsbury 21 Feb. 1669/70, d. there 2 May 1717, son of John and Abiah (Gillett) Slater; m. (3) Deacon Samuel
      Marshal l (not Thomas Yarahall, as Nathaniel Goodwin says), and she survived him also. William Case had seven children.

      v. Samuel , b. Windsor 1 June 1667; d. Simsbury, 30 July 172S;
      m. (1) Mary Westover, dau. of Jonas and Hannah (Griswold) Westover, who d. 27 Sept. 1713;
      m. {2) at Simsbury, 8 Nov. 1721, Elizabeth Owen, b. there 19 Nov. 1684, dau. of Josiah and Mary (Osborn) Owen, and widow of Samuel Thrall (thirteen children by Mary, one by Elizabeth).

      vi. Richard, b. Windsor 27 Aug. 1669; d. Simsbury ca. 1746;
      m. at Simsbury, 1 Sept. 1701, Amy Read, dau. of Dr. Philip Reade of Concord, Mass., by his wife Abigail Rice. This was a double wedding with his sister Abigail (eight children).

      vii. Bartholomew, b. Simsbury Oct. 1670; d. there, 25 Oct. 1725; m. there, 7 Dec. 1699, Mary Humphrey, b. 16 Nov. 1681, d. after 1725, dau. of Samuel and Mary (Mills) Humphrey (nine children).

      viii. Joseph, b. Simsbury 6 Apr. 1674; d. there 11 Aug. 1748; m. there, 6 Apr. 1699, Anna Eno, b. 10 Apr. 1682, d. 10 June 1760 at Simsbury, dau. of James Eno (eight children).

      ix. Sarah, b. Simsbury 20 Apr. 1676 (or Windsor 14 Apr. 1676 by Grant record) ; d. Simsbury 2 May 1704; m. there, 4 Nov. 1699, as second wife, Joseph3 Phelps (Joseph2, W:illiam.l ), b. Windsor 20 Aug. 1667, d . Simsbury 20 Jan. 1749/50. He m. (1) before Oct. 1689, Macy Collyer b . ca. 1669, dau. of Joseph and Elizabeth (Sanford) Collyer of Hartford; (2) as above
      stated; and (3) ca. 1706, Mary ___ , alleged by the Phelps Genealogy (l:l04-107), and perhaps rightly, to
      have been Mary Case, dau. of Richard* and Elizabeth (Purchase) Case, on whom see below. He had three children by Mary Collyer, two by Sarah Case, four by the third wife.

      x. Abigail, b. Simsbury 4 May 1682; d. after 1725; m. at Simsbury, 1 Sept. 1701 (in a double wedding with her brother Richard), Jonas Westover, bapt. at Windsor 20 Sept. 1664, d. at Simsbury 3 June 171L, son of Jonas and Hannah (Griswold) Westover; five children.

      * "As yet no document has been discovered which connects
      John Case with Richard Case, though it may be
      that they were successively, as we have have seen, father-
      in-law to Joseph Phelps."
      *************************************************
      Sources for the information given below?

      John Case, 1616 - 1703John Case was born in Aylesham, England circa 1616 and died 21 Feb 1703 (or 1704 or 1705) in Simsbury, CT. The Case family is one of the ancient and honorable families of New England. They were noted as far back as Oliver Cromwell (1599-1659) and accumulated a fortune furnishing leather for the Army, being tanners and farniers. The records show they came from York, England to Aylesham, England in the year 1200. They held all the land around Aylesham so the town was said to be Cased in and were a clan by themselves. Many of them still reside there. Their land surrounded possessions of Anna Boleyn, who became the second wife of Henry VIII of England, and was beheaded "for treason" in 1536. The Cases were closely related by intermarriage to the Boleyns. John arrived in New England on the ship "Dorsett" on September 3, 1635 from Gravesend, England, at the age of 19 years. The ship landed around Long Island. He then moved to Dorchester, MA [1]. In 1637 John married Sarah Spencer (1636-1691), daughter of William and Agnes (Tucker) Spencer of Hartford, CT. They next moved to Hartford, then moved to Maspeth Kills, NY (now Newton according to our Genealogy). John and Sarah resided in Windsor CT from 1656 until 1669, when they removed to Simsbury and settled in the area known as "Weatogue" [3]. In 1667 John, with twenty others, received the first grant of land in Simsbury which was at Meadow Plain, Massaco (Simsbury). He lived about one mile south of the Pettibone Tavern, the second house south. He was a shoemaker and harness maker as well as a farmer. He was appointed constable for Massaco by the General Court Oct. 14, 1669, and represented his town at the General Court in 1670 and several times afterwards. He with six sons would go from Weatogue to what now (1900) is West Simsbury and cultivate the land there. Hence it was first called Case's Farms, afterwards Farms Village, then West Simsbury. They carried their guns with them as a protection from the Indians as well as to shoot game which was very plentiful there. The first of 5 children to John and Sarah were born in Windsor, the last 5 were born in Simsbury: Elizabeth born 1658 in Windsor; died 9 Oct 1718; married (1) Joseph Lewis; married (2) John Tuller Mary born 22 Jun 1660 in Windsor; died 22 Aug 1725; married (1) 1677/9 William Alderman who died 1697; married (2) 30 Mar 1698/9 James Hilliard who died 28 July 1720, age 76.



  • Sources 
    1. [S943] Ancestrial File/Family Search, (Familysearch.org/) (The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints.).

    2. [S938] Robert Sheldon Telford, Robert Sheldon Telford.

    3. [S942] Spencer - Huxley (online), Compiled by Stephen M. Lawson,, (13 Apr 1998, http://sml.simplenet.com/smlawson/spencer.htm).

    4. [S939] Associated Families of Gregory D. Maxwell, Compiled by Gregory D. Maxfield, (http://www.pacifier.com/!gregdm/ Lincoln, Henry Spencer).

    5. [S962] Descendants of William Case, Daniel E. Case, (http://www.familytreemaker.com/users/c/a/s/Daniel-E-Case/GENNE5-0001.html).

    6. [S260] Aldermans in America, Parker pg 18, Parker, William Alderman.

    7. [S1160] FamilySearch Family Tree (http://www.familysearch.org), The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, ((http://www.familysearch.org)), accessed 12 Dec 2022), entry for John CASE, person ID LB8D-PFQ. (Reliability: 3).

    8. [S261] Register Report, Sam Behling, (http://www.genweb.net/~samcasey/).